Where are they now?

The former members of Reality Scare continue to Make the Noise:

Greg and Clare have gone on to form Afterglow, an Avant-Filk band.

Dave makes the noise in various freeform settings throughout Chicago.
This is one of his recent collaborations.

Mary is preparing to unleash her own take on things soon.
We're not sure what it will be, exactly, but it will undoubtedly be damn intense!